Puffenbarger Insurance

Warrenton, VA office

Contact us today about your insurance needs.

(4.8)

Read our reviews

73 W Lee Hwy
Warrenton, VA 20186

(540) 347-7322 · Call
Call

Email Us

Meet the Team

Request Quote

What kind of insurance do you need?

Business Insurance and Services

Home, Auto, Life and More

Industry-Specific Programs

Contact Us

First and Last Name *

Email Address *

City and State *

Phone *

Can we send you text / SMS messages? *

By selecting 'Yes' you consent to receive conversational text / SMS messages from Puffenbarger Insurance. Reply STOP to opt-out, reply HELP for support. Message and data rates apply. Messaging frequency may vary. Privacy policy

Question or Comment *

Please note: coverage cannot be bound or altered online. A service representative will need to contact you to finalize your request.

Office details

Phone Numbers

(540) 347-7322 - Main

Office Address

73 W Lee Hwy
Warrenton, VA 20186

Map · Office Staff

Hours

Day	Time
Mon	9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Tue	9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Wed	9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Thr	9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Fri	9:00 AM – 3:30 PM
Sat	Closed
Sun	Closed

Times listed in Pacific Time

Map of Puffinbarger Insurance - Warrenton, Virginia

What our clients are saying about us

“My family has been with Puffenbarger Insurance and Financial Services since 2022, and I couldn’t be more pleased with the experience. Tonette, in particular, has been incredibly helpful. She’s always quick to respond to any questions we have, whether by email or phone call, and her customer service is top-notch. The entire team is professional and dedicated, making sure that we are well taken care of. We are extremely happy with the service provided and highly recommend Puffenbarger Insurance and Financial Services to anyone looking for reliable and attentive support.”

C

christina mcalpine
“Puffenbarger made switching my home and automobile insurance very easy. By switching my plan to them, I was able to get a much better rate and excellent customer service. My experience was seamless and I’m appreciative of the team at Puffenbarger for taking such great care of my needs.”

M

Michelle DeHaven
“Diane Beechrel is the kindest and most compassionate member. She has been very helpful to me and explains information. Always available to take a question or concern. Recently helped with some homeowners insurance issues. Thank you Diane!”

S

Shelia Sale
“I had a very pleasant experience working with Victoria to go over my insurance options. She was very friendly and extremely knowledgeable and just a pleasure to deal with and that reflects positively on Puffenbarger Insurance. Thank you.”

S

SteveB
“I've been a client for over 20 years. Their service has been outstanding and recommendations quite helpful. Shout out to Victoria Counihan, my agent primary contact!”

P

Patrick Zazzaro
“I had the pleasure of working with Tonnette of Nationwide. She was friendly and knowledgeable and I was completely impressed with her professionalism and knowledge. She was easy to communicate with and explained various plans and guides in selecting a policy that suits my needs best. I highly recommend her to anyone looking for an insurance agency that puts customers first.”

I

I M
“My experience with Puffenbarger Insurance and Financial Services is exemplary. Every interaction with them is so professional and quickly addressed. When I don’t understand something they are so patient and informative. They respond immediately to any email requests and are so helpful when I just stop in with a question. I highly recommend this company!”

B

Bonnie Chamberlain
“Kristen Clarckson has been wonderful. She communicates effectively and advocates on our behalf with the claims department.”

A

Amy Rahhal
“Puffenbarger provides all our insurance needs.Professional, competent, friendly and prompt service. Highly recommended.”

M

Mike Keenan
“Wilton Elmore and his team member Cathy Powell have been extremely professional and very responsive to my needs as a small business owner. Wilton provided insight and guidance that helped me with my business insurance needs. The enrollment and payment process was seamless. They also offer additional insights and educational information afterwards. I highly recommend their services.”

I

Ines R
“My agent Diane Beecherl is always available with help and perfect advice. Years ago she was recommended to me by a friend….I am so happy I made this choice. Thank you Diane!”

C

Charla Hayen
“Puffenbarger worked with me to get home and auto insurance that I needed at a good price.i don't think they can be beaten.”

D

Dickie Maddox
“Kathy Powell was very responsive to my request for quote, and clear in her explanation of my questions. I liked working with them.”

V

Vijay Kumar
“Victoria C did a thorough and accurate quick job preparing our homeowners insurance on our new home!”

C

Cathie Holdway
“Our nonprofit has been clients of Puffenburger Insurance and Financial Services for many years. We are always impressed by their willingness to help us with any questions. They have always been very professional, however at the same time very kind.”

P

Peggy Baker
“My homeowners insurance premium had gone up, so I was searching for a new company. When I did an online search, Puffenbarger Insurance had the best rate. I had a long conversation with Tonette and she got me all squared away. She was very personable, knowledgable and efficient. I also read about the company and discovered it is a well respected insurance agency.”

M

Marilyn Williams
“Scott is always a huge help and looks at all options to make the best decision possible.”

C

Chip Miller
“Kristen has been my rep for home, auto, life, and umbrella policies for a few years now. Been a great experience working with her!”

L

Leah Abrahamson
“Cathy worked really hard to find the right insurance for my needs.”

I

Ingrid Hohlfelder
“Tonette was very professional and very personable. It was a pleasure working with her.”

B

Bud Trenum
“I was able to meet Kristen at the Culpeper office yesterday. Switching insurance sometimes seems like a big job when you have autos and the mortgage companies to work with. She made my transition from my old company to their agency easy as can be. I could not be happier than the way I was treated as a person while getting the right policy set up I needed. I am one happy customer.”

R

Richard Maddox
“Their service is impeccable. I am a small company and wear many hats and hate to deal with paperwork and they made this so easy for me.”

T

Terry Malone
“Puffenbarger Insurance is responsive and easy to work with. We have been with them for over seven years and highly recommend them for insurance needs.”

L

Lynn B
“Kristen is the best! Would highly recommend for all your insurance needs”

C

Caren Johnson
“I felt that I was treated courteously and quickly by all associates that i interacted with on several separate occasions. I was pleased with the service I received.”

D

David Cooper
“Ian is very responsive and knowledgeable. He is a pleasure to do business with and helps ensure our insurance needs are taken care of in the proper fashion.”

L

Lisa Mallam
“Tonette was fabulous! She helped us get a quote much lower than other insurance companies. She was professional and very helpful!”

F

Flora Duvall
“Scott and Jack have been true professionals when they helped me with my personal insurances. They reviewed my prior coverage and identified some holes as well as some over coverages and provided us with solutions to properly cover our risk. This gives my family and me the peace of mind to know we are properly covered if we ever have the unfortunate need to use it. Further, I proudly provide Scott and Jack referrals when my friends and clients need a second look at their coverage. I am confident that they will take great care of them and deliver the same level of service and respect I would show them myself. Thank you both for your professionalism.”

A

Amelia Stansell
“I have been a Nationwide client for 40 years and have always received accurate information, friendly and prompt customer service and wouldn't think of looking anywhere else for my insurance needs. Great company, easy-to-read statement, simple online access. The Puffenbarger/Stone agency has provided excellent service.”

B

Brenda Jenkins
“I have nothing but the best to say for the two folks I interact with at Puffenbarger. They are fantastic, and I am so grateful for the work they do for my business, and my personal account!”

J

Jason Murnock
“I have been a client with this agency for more then 30yrs. I have always been completely happy with their customer service and assistance with managing my policies. Kelly Stone and Kristan Clarkson have been an absolute pleasure to work with. They have both gone above and beyond to help me. We have recently relocated to South Carolina and will no longer be insured by Puffenbarger insurance. I have to say that I feel like I am leaving my friends. Kristen and Kelly help me so much with my transition. I will have to call them every now and then just to say hi. Thanks again, Marilyn Alvarado”

J

julio alvarado
“Professional, expert advice. Cares about community - $50 rebate from Nationwide unexpected, and gracious. Staff is knowledgeable, no pressure, and easy to work with, They provided me workable options for both my personal and business needs. Very quick at following up, even during this time of pandemic in our country. Felt like they treat large customers and small customers with the same level of professionalism and courtesy.”

T

TIMOTHY FRANEY
“I can't say enough good things about Puffenbarger Insurance Company. They have been nothing short of amazing—always going above and beyond to ensure I have the best coverage and support when I need it most. Their dedication and loyalty to their customers truly set them apart from the rest. Every interaction I've had with their team has been professional, friendly, and incredibly helpful. They don’t just meet the standard; they exceed it in every way possible. Whether it's answering my questions, handling claims efficiently, or just providing peace of mind, they consistently go the extra mile. If you're looking for an insurance company that truly cares about you and puts your needs first, look no further!!! Highly recommend!”

Dawn Malone
“Theysaid to me, "You don't have to worry. I will be your personal agent." This has been true since we bought our first home in Virginia. This agency takes care of their clients and ascertains their needs are met with a definite personal touch.”

Gania Howard
“Diane was amazing! She is such and kind and patient representative. She very knowledgeable and helpful.”

Kathy Parrish
“Tonette has helped me for decades. She is always responsive and looks out for my best interest. I highly recommend insuring with this company.”

Laurie Penland
“15 minutes of speaking with them saved me more than 15% when shopping around for comprehensive auto quotes. Friendly and always answering their phones! Thanks Tonette!”

Marius Mello
“Every agent I've interacted with at Puffenbarger has responded quickly and went above and beyond to meet my needs. Would definitely recommend for all your insurance needs.”

Monti Board
“The Puffenbarger team has been exceptional to work with in reviewing various POA and HOA policies for our association management organization. Cathy, Michelle, Stephanie, and Greg have each been very responsive and especially courteous and professional. It's been a pleasure working with each of them. Jack's experience and guidance is second to none. He goes above and beyond simply being present for renewals or new business. He takes the time to share insurance tips with myself and my team which are relative to our industry and he proactively offers to come to our office to provide insurance education to association managers.”

Tara Armstrong

Meet Our Team—Warrenton, VA

Cathy Powell

Commercial Account Manager

Diane Beecherl

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Finn Maenza

Personal Lines CSR

Greg Burns

Commercial Account Manager

Ian Fraser

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Jack Mallam

Agency Co-Owner

Jeannette Fuchs

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Matthew Duckworth

Personal Insurance Advisor

Michelle Paiva

Commercial Insurance Account Manager

Sally Flores

Commercial Insurance Service Manager

Santiago Masaya

Customer Service Representative

Scott Puffenbarger

Agency Co-Owner

Vicki Elmore

VP of Business Operations

Victoria Counihan

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Wilton Elmore

Commercial Insurance Advisor

View all office locations »

Web Accessibility

Warrenton, VA office

Contact us today about your insurance needs.

What kind of insurance do you need?

Contact Us

Office details

Phone Numbers

Office Address

Hours

What our clients are saying about us

Meet Our Team—Warrenton, VA

Cathy Powell

Diane Beecherl

Finn Maenza

Greg Burns

Ian Fraser

Jack Mallam

Jeannette Fuchs

Matthew Duckworth

Michelle Paiva

Sally Flores

Santiago Masaya

Scott Puffenbarger

Vicki Elmore

Victoria Counihan

Wilton Elmore

Business Insurance

Business Owner's Insurance

Commercial Auto Insurance

Commercial Property Insurance

Commercial Umbrella Insurance

Cyber Liability Insurance

Executive & Professional Liability

General Liability

Professional Liability Insurance

Workers Compensation

Agribusiness Insurance

Agritourism Insurance

Construction Insurance

Farm & Ranch Program

Winery Insurance

Boat Insurance

Car Insurance

Classic Car Insurance

Flood Insurance

Home & Condo Insurance

Identity Theft Insurance

Law Enforcement Officer Insurance

Life Insurance

Personal Insurance

Personal Umbrella Coverage

Pet Insurance

Recreational Vehicle Insurance

Renters Insurance